The world of Thedas is a complex and morally ambiguous place, filled with difficult choices that can have lasting consequences. One of the most infamous choices players encounter in Dragon Age: Origins is the decision of whether or not to take the coin from Cullen. This seemingly simple act can lead to a chain reaction of events, impacting your relationships, gameplay, and even the fate of the world.
The Context: A Story of Trust and Betrayal
Cullen, the stoic and duty-bound Templar, is a character players encounter early in their journey. He is entrusted with guarding the Grey Wardens, a group of warriors sworn to fight the Blight, a deadly fungal infection that threatens to destroy Thedas. Cullen, despite his loyalty, is haunted by a past filled with trauma and a struggle with the taint. He is also struggling with his own inner demons, battling the effects of lyrium, a substance used to combat the Blight.
The coin in question represents a symbol of this struggle. It is a talisman, infused with lyrium, meant to help Cullen fight the taint. It is also a physical manifestation of his internal conflict, reminding him of the dangers of his addiction. The choice to take the coin is a complex one, forcing players to confront themes of trust, loyalty, and the consequences of our actions.
The Arguments For Taking the Coin:
- Helping Cullen: Taking the coin can be seen as a way to help Cullen cope with his struggles. By removing the talisman, you could potentially alleviate some of the pressure and pain he experiences. This act could be interpreted as a gesture of compassion and a desire to alleviate his suffering.
- Power Boost: The coin itself is a powerful magical artifact. It can be used to enchant your armor or weapons, giving you a significant edge in combat. For players prioritizing combat strength and efficiency, the coin represents a tangible reward for their actions.
- Moral Ambiguity: The game itself doesn’t outright condemn taking the coin. In fact, the dialogue options presented allow for different interpretations of the situation. This leaves room for players to justify their actions based on their own personal moral compass and understanding of the story.
The Arguments Against Taking the Coin:
- Betraying Cullen’s Trust: The coin holds deep significance for Cullen, representing his struggle and his commitment to his duty. Taking it without his consent can be seen as a betrayal of his trust. This could have a negative impact on your relationship with him, potentially leading to conflict and resentment.
- Fueling Addiction: While taking the coin may alleviate Cullen’s immediate suffering, it could also fuel his dependency on lyrium. By removing the talisman, you could potentially be hindering his progress in overcoming his addiction and pushing him further into dangerous territory.
- Consequences in the Future: Your decision to take the coin can have far-reaching consequences in the later stages of the game. While the game doesn’t explicitly state these consequences, the potential for future conflict and betrayal looms large, creating a sense of uncertainty and anticipation.
The Importance of Roleplay and Player Agency:
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to take the coin is a personal one. There is no “right” or “wrong” answer, and each player will make their choice based on their individual preferences and understanding of the story.
- Roleplay: If you are playing a character who prioritizes empathy and compassion, you might choose to leave the coin for Cullen, showing respect for his struggle and his personal journey.
- Personal Morals: If you believe that the coin should be used for its magical benefits, regardless of its emotional significance, you might choose to take it, justifying your actions as necessary for the greater good.
Exploring the Consequences of Your Choice
The choice you make regarding the coin will have a lasting impact on your journey in Dragon Age: Origins. While the immediate consequences may be subtle, they can ripple throughout the game, influencing future dialogue options, relationships, and even the ending of the story.
- Relationships: Taking the coin can negatively impact your relationship with Cullen, potentially leading to conflict and distrust. This could affect your ability to work with him later in the game, particularly if you need his help or support.
- Gameplay: The coin offers a powerful magical enchantment that can be used to enhance your character’s abilities. This can significantly impact your gameplay experience, giving you a strategic advantage in combat and exploration.
- The Story: The coin is a symbol of Cullen’s internal struggle, and your choice to take or leave it will reflect your understanding of his character and his journey. This can influence the way you perceive the story and the choices you make later in the game.
The Importance of Critical Thinking:
Whether you choose to take the coin or not, it is important to consider the implications of your actions. The game doesn’t always provide clear-cut answers, forcing you to think critically and make difficult choices. This is part of what makes Dragon Age: Origins such a compelling and engaging experience.
- Beyond the Surface: The coin is more than just a magical artifact. It is a symbol of Cullen’s struggle, his vulnerability, and his commitment to duty.
- Long-Term Consequences: Your choices in Dragon Age: Origins have long-term consequences, and your decision regarding the coin is no exception.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to take the coin from Cullen is a complex one, offering no easy answers. It is a decision that will reflect your understanding of the story, your personal morals, and your roleplaying style. Whatever choice you make, embrace the ambiguity, consider the consequences, and enjoy the journey through the world of Thedas.
FAQs
What happens if I take the coin from Cullen?
Taking the coin from Cullen will result in him becoming hostile and attacking you. He will also be permanently removed from your party, and you will not be able to recruit him again. This choice also affects Cullen’s character arc in later games, as he will be resentful of the Warden for betraying him. However, taking the coin does grant you access to a unique and powerful artifact.
Ultimately, whether or not to take the coin is a moral decision. If you value loyalty and trust, then it is best to leave the coin alone. However, if you are driven by the need to acquire powerful artifacts, then taking the coin may be the right choice for you.
What happens if I refuse the coin from Cullen?
Refusing the coin from Cullen will allow you to maintain a positive relationship with him. He will continue to be a loyal and valuable member of your party, and he will not become hostile towards you. This decision also sets the stage for a more positive relationship with Cullen in later games, as he will appreciate your trustworthiness. However, you will miss out on the unique and powerful artifact that is associated with the coin.
This decision emphasizes loyalty and trust over personal gain. If you prioritize building strong relationships and maintaining a positive reputation, then refusing the coin is the right choice. But if you prioritize acquiring powerful items and forging your own path, then taking the coin might be more appealing.
What is the significance of the coin?
The coin Cullen offers is a powerful artifact known as the “Coin of the Keeper.” It grants the wielder immense power, but it also comes with a heavy price. The coin is rumored to be cursed, and many believe that it can corrupt the wielder’s soul. It is important to note that the coin is not essential for progressing through the game, and there are other ways to obtain similar power.
The coin represents a moral dilemma. It offers a tempting reward, but also carries a heavy risk. This choice forces the player to confront the consequences of their actions and consider the long-term impact of their decisions.
Does taking the coin affect my relationship with Alistair?
Taking the coin from Cullen will not directly affect your relationship with Alistair, but it can have indirect consequences. If Alistair is a member of your party when you take the coin, he will disapprove of your actions. He values loyalty and honesty, and he will see your decision as a betrayal of Cullen. However, this disapproval will not necessarily lead to a major conflict or a break in your relationship.
The impact of your decision on Alistair is subtle. It highlights the importance of consistency in your actions and how your choices can influence your relationships with other characters. While it might not cause a dramatic shift, it reflects your values and how you handle moral dilemmas.
Can I still get the artifact if I refuse the coin?
No, you cannot obtain the artifact if you refuse the coin from Cullen. This decision permanently locks you out of acquiring the “Coin of the Keeper.” However, there are other ways to obtain powerful artifacts and items throughout the game. You can explore different dungeons, complete side quests, and engage in crafting to acquire valuable gear and weapons.
This choice emphasizes the importance of making a decision with a clear understanding of the consequences. It also highlights the presence of alternative paths and the possibility of acquiring valuable items through different means.
What are the long-term implications of taking the coin?
Taking the coin from Cullen has long-term implications for both your character and the world of Thedas. The coin’s power can corrupt the wielder, leading to negative consequences down the line. It can also affect your relationships with other characters, particularly with those who value loyalty and honesty. The coin’s presence can also influence future events, potentially triggering unforeseen consequences in subsequent games.
Taking the coin highlights the weight of decisions in the game. It shows how your actions can have consequences that extend beyond the immediate situation, shaping your character’s destiny and influencing the world around them.
What are the long-term implications of refusing the coin?
Refusing the coin from Cullen sets the stage for a more positive relationship with him and potentially other characters who value honesty and loyalty. It also allows you to maintain a consistent moral compass, avoiding the potential corruption associated with the coin. However, it means you miss out on a powerful artifact that could have significantly impacted your character’s abilities and influence in the game.
Refusing the coin reflects a commitment to personal values and a willingness to make sacrifices for the sake of integrity. It highlights the importance of prioritizing relationships and ethical choices, even when faced with tempting opportunities.